Tribunal challenges Knebworth estate price rises

Haygarth, Knebworth

Haygarth, Knebworth - Credit: Archant

A mother-of-two from Knebworth said she feels like a “hostage” after a housing association more than doubled its service charge for leaseholders.

A trubunal has opened after Hightown Praetorian & Churches Housing Association Ltd (HP) increased charges on flats in Haygarth Estate on January 1.

Rate rises differ between blocks, but in the majority of cases it has increased between £50 and £70 per month, making it around £123.

HP are also demanding trust fund contributions from leaseholds to the tune of £3,150 for renovation work.

Last year residents paid £250.


You may also want to watch:


Forty two properties are affected.

Leaseholder and mother-of-two Cahrlotte Bright said: “I am a single mother of two and I have been trying to sell my house.

Most Read

“I was told if you don’t like it, move. Our properties will be un-sellable, it [the service charge] is another mortgage on top of it. I am desperately trying to get out but feel like I am being held hostage by Hightown on the estate.”

A tribunal was held last Monday in Welwyn Garden City, between HP and Haygarth leaseholder Paul Clark, to dispute the new charges.

Residents do not agree with having to pay higher rates, claiming HP has “mismanaged” the properties and failed to communicate with them.

Mr Clark, a management consultant, said: “We accept the work has to be done, the only issue is the timing and the money is collected in a way which is affordable to people. I am frustrated I think all this was avoidable.”

The tribunal has now been adjourned but will continue later in the year after a joint application by the leaseholders of Haygarth has been submitted.

A spokesman from Hightown Praetorian & Churches Housing Association Ltd, said: “Hightown is obliged to maintain the estate and the structure of the buildings and recovers the costs through service charges.

“Hightown is seeking a ruling from the tribunal about the reasonableness of the service charge at Haygarth.

“We understand the reasons for the tribunal adjournment but were disappointed that we were not given the chance to present our case last week.”

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter