Ian Stewart given whole life order for murder of wife Diane
- Credit: Herts police
Convicted killer Ian Stewart has been given a whole life order for the murder of his wife Diane in Bassingbourn in 2010 - six years before he murdered Royston children's author Helen Bailey.
Police investigated the death of Diane Stewart after Stewart was sentenced to 34 years in prison for murdering Ms Bailey and dumping her body, and that of her dog Boris, in a cesspit in the family home.
Stewart, from Letchworth, was found guilty of murdering Diane - whose death was initially attributed to SUDEP (sudden unexpected death in epilepsy) - in Huntingdon Crown Court today, by a jury of five men and seven women.
The judge, Mr Justice Simon Bryan, said the two women's deaths were in "chillingly similar circumstances".
He told Stewart: "You successfully passed off a murder as an epileptic fit in the circumstance I have identified playing out an elaborate, and indeed sophisticated, charade over a period of time.
"A charade that succeeded at the time, and would have succeeded for all time but for your subsequent murder of Helen Bailey."
Stewart had claimed in court, as his two sons listened to his evidence, that he had returned from the supermarket to the family home in Bassingbourn, Cambridgeshire, and found his wife collapsed in the garden.
He said he thought she had suffered an epileptic fit.
Mrs Stewart had not had an epileptic fit for 18 years and took daily medication, jurors were told, with consultant neurologist Dr Christopher Derry estimating that her risk of having a fatal epileptic seizure was about one in 100,000.
During a 999 call Stewart was instructed to perform CPR on his wife and said he was doing so, but paramedic Spencer North, who attended the scene, said there "didn't seem to be any effective CPR".
Mrs Stewart's death was not treated as suspicious at the time and, while a post-mortem examination was carried out, it was not a forensic post-mortem.
As part of the police investigation, following Stewart's 2017 murder conviction, consultant neuropathologist Professor Safa Al-Sarraj was asked to examine preserved parts of Mrs Stewart's brain, which had been donated to medical science.
Prof Al-Sarraj said there was evidence that Mrs Stewart's brain had suffered a lack of oxygen prior to her death, and he estimated that this happened over a period of 35 minutes to an hour.
The judge told Stewart: "It no doubt never crossed your mind that the donation of Diane's brain for teaching and research would lead to your ultimate downfall, as it was to do, and your conviction today for the murder of Diane Stewart, for which I must now sentence you."
Prosecutor Stuart Trimmer QC said her death was "most likely caused by a prolonged restriction to her breathing from an outside source", such as smothering or a neck hold.
Home Office pathologist Dr Nat Cary described SUDEP as a "diagnosis of exclusion", adding that "an equal diagnosis of exclusion is having been put into such a state by some covert means - smothering or interfering with the mechanics of breathing or some kind of drug use".
The court heard that full toxicology was not carried out as part of the 2010 routine post-mortem examination, and nor was a neck dissection.
Dr Cary said that, as in the case of Mrs Stewart, there was "no injury that was visible" in the case of Ms Bailey, who was in the cesspit for three months before she was found.
The court heard that Stewart received £96,607.37 after his wife's death, in the form of £28,500.21 from a life insurance policy and the rest from bank accounts.
Both of the couple's sons were out on the day of their mother's death, with then 15-year-old Oliver at school and Jamie, then 18, taking his driving test.
Jamie Stewart had told the court that he recalled "raised voices... between my mother and father" when he was at home on study leave for A-levels the week his mother died.
- 1 9 things to do on a day trip to Hitchin, Hertfordshire
- 2 Herts' 'league of extraordinary farmers' come together to fight field fires
- 3 Music festival Old Town Live set to return with stages in High Street and venues across Stevenage Old Town
- 4 August 2022 weekend closure planned for A602 near Watton-at-Stone
- 5 Van 'tactically stopped' on A1(M) after alleged attempted vehicle theft
- 6 Incredible finish at the Lamex as Stevenage beat Stockport County
- 7 Deserved win for Stevenage over Stockport says Steve Evans but it was definitely in doubt
- 8 Thameslink suffers 'staff shortage' with weekend disruption planned
- 9 Pups turn fancy dress influencers to raise funds for animal charity
- 10 North Herts and Stevenage set for scorching 29C by the end of next week
The judge said he was "satisfied that the major motive for Diane's murder was for financial gain" but had "no doubt that there were other subsidiary motives".
He said it will "never be possible to be sure" but there was a suggestion that "all was not well" in the defendant's marriage and that he was "tiring of Diane".
The defendant, flanked by four dock officers, looked towards his two sons who sat in the public gallery as he was led to the cells, but they did not make eye contact with him.