Controversial former Hitchin politician David Leal-Bennett censured tonight – as it’s revealed council disciplinary process costs taxpayer a cool £67,000

Controversial former Hitchin councillor David Leal-Bennett was censured tonight - at a total cost of

Controversial former Hitchin councillor David Leal-Bennett was censured tonight - at a total cost of £67,000 to the taxpayer over the whole process. - Credit: Archant

A former Hitchin politician was censured tonight at a meeting of North Herts District Council after a debate on his previous conduct – as it was revealed the true of cost of the process against him this year amounted to nearly £70,000 of taxpayers’ money.

Councillors at Gernon Road in Letchworth voted 16 in favour - with six against - to censure former councillor David Leal-Bennett relating to charges of a failure to observe five codes of conduct at a disciplinary hearing back in February.

However, there was controversy as former local councillor Mr Leal-Bennett called for the resignation of the leader of the council, Lynda Needham, during absorbing discussions that had the packed chamber listening intently.

In a stinging counter-attack David Leal-Bennett, speaking as a member of the public, demanded the head of North Herts District Council Lynda Needham after a bitter fallout relating to the long-running Hitchin Town Hall and museum saga which has been estimated to have already cost the taxpayer more than £1 million.

The fall-out comes from a three-day hearing in February convened to investigative evidence over councillor Leal-Bennett’s alleged breaching of the councillor’s code of conduct, from complaints made in March 2015 relating to a council meeting about Hitchin Town Hall Ltd.

The complaints stem from Mr Leal-Bennett’s involvement as a trustee and director of Hitchin Town Hall Limited – HTH Ltd – and his behaviour as a councillor, including refusing to leave the council chamber during a meeting held in January 2015 in which officials said his presence in the debate was a conflict of interest.

The February standards committee heard accusations of a ‘blame culture of fear and intimidation’ levelled at North Herts District Council – but five charges out of nine against him were upheld relating to him breaching council codes of conduct.

Most Read

Mr Leal-Bennett later lost his seat as a Conservative Hitchin councillor in the local elections in May as the Liberal Democrats triumphed in the ward of Hitchin Highbury – prompting Lib Dem leader Tim Farron to send his congratulations to the winner Paul Clark via the Comet.

However, speaking to a rapt audience before the council voted to censure him for his previous behaviour – at the last ever meeting in the Gernon Road chamber before a multi-million pound revamp – Mr Leal-Bennett pulled no punches stating: “I hold the councillor [Lynda Needham] fully responsible for this situation.

“She should consider her position as leader of the council.

“NHDC spent hundreds of thousands of pounds on obtaining the advice of a QC despite withholding crucial information.

“Fortunately a long police investigation was closed with no action being taken against me – but NHDC then initiated a full scale attack on me.”

The censure debate heard from many councillors including from the Lib Dems Steve Jarvis who said: “I find it strange to censure someone for their behaviour as a councillor when they are not a councillor any more.”

Labour’s Lizzie Dennis added: “I can’t support the motion to censure David Leal-Bennett. The council brought in a senior barrister at a very expensive rate.

“It’s a very sad day for the council and I hope that there are strong lessons to be learned from it. “

There were audible gasps as it was revealed the total cost of following the due process to censure Mr Leal-Bennett totalled £67,902.

Reacting to the figure Conservative councillor Nicola Harris blasted; “No wonder we are having a budget cut.

“I have to say David was a very good ward councillor. I cannot support the motion.”

Councillor Terry Hone responded: “I’m very disappointed we are talking about money – either we follow due process or we don’t.

“We can’t say we haven’t got the money to have a standards board.

“Yes, lawyers are expensive but if you want proper due process so we can be independent it has to be paid for. It is a process we have to go through.”

Speaking exclusively to the Comet after the findings Mr Leal-Bennett concluded: “In any democracy there is the ability to appeal a decision and it is a basic human right. I do not wish to incur further cost but I need to clear my name.

“I do not accept the charges against me.”

It is understood by the Comet if Mr Leal-Bennett wishes to contest a Hitchin seat in a future election he is allowed to do so, despite the £67,000 censure.

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter